This town hall is notable since multiple people had medical emergencies and for the last 30 minutes Donald Trump stopped answering questions to instead play music for everyone.
During the 2024 Presidential Election campaign, former President Donald Trump's conventional town hall in Oaks, Pennsylvania on October 14, 2024—just 22 days before Election Day—transformed unexpectedly into a 45-minute musical performance after two medical emergencies interrupted the event. As reported by ABC News, NPR, and the Associated Press, Trump abandoned the planned question-and-answer format moderated by South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem after just four audience questions, instead playing selections including Sinead O'Connor's "Nothing Compares 2 U," Rufus Wainwright's "Hallelujah," and Guns N' Roses' "November Rain" while "bopping and shimmying onstage." The incident occurred on the same day Vice President Kamala Harris was also campaigning in Pennsylvania, highlighting the battleground state's crucial role in determining the electoral outcome of what polling indicated was an extremely close race. Trump campaign officials characterized the unconventional pivot positively, with Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt stating it created a "room full of joy" and spokesperson Steven Cheung noting on social media platform X that Trump "is unlike any politician in history," while Harris later responded by reposting video of Trump swaying to music with the comment "Hope he's okay."
On Monday, October 14, 2024, former President Donald Trump held what was scheduled as a traditional town hall event at the Greater Philadelphia Expo Center and Fairgrounds in Oaks, Pennsylvania. The event, occurring exactly 22 days before the November 5 presidential election, initially followed a standard campaign format with South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem serving as moderator for a question-and-answer session with audience members. As reported by ABC News, NPR, and the Associated Press, what began as a conventional town hall transformed into an unplanned musical performance following medical emergencies in the audience.
Pennsylvania, with its crucial electoral votes, remains a focal point for both major candidates in the 2024 presidential election. The simultaneous campaign appearances by Trump in Oaks and Vice President Kamala Harris elsewhere in Pennsylvania that same day underscore the state's pivotal role in the election's outcome.
According to ABC News reporting, approximately 30 minutes into the event, after Trump had answered just four audience questions, the first of two medical emergencies occurred. The report states that one attendee "required to be placed on a stretcher" while the crowd began singing "God Bless America." All three news sources confirmed that Trump requested "Ave Maria" be played on the loudspeakers as medics tended to the affected person.
Following a second medical incident, Trump and Governor Noem both commented on the uncomfortable temperature in the venue. ABC News reported that "Trump requested that the doors be opened but he was advised that for security reasons that wasn't possible." According to AP News, Noem made a comment about the lack of air conditioning, stating, "They probably can't afford it, sir, in this economy."
After these disruptions, Trump made the decision to pivot away from the town hall format, saying according to ABC News: "Let's not do any more questions. Let's just listen to music. Let's make it into a music fest. Who the hell wants to hear questions right? Isn't that beautiful?" This represented a significant departure from traditional campaign events during the final weeks before Election Day.
All three news sources confirmed that Trump remained on stage for approximately 40-45 minutes during the musical portion of the event. AP News provided the most comprehensive account of the musical selections, reporting that the playlist included Sinead O'Connor's "Nothing Compares 2 U," Rufus Wainwright's cover of "Hallelujah," Guns N' Roses' "November Rain," and "Memory" from the musical "Cats." NPR noted that Trump specifically requested Luciano Pavarotti's version of "Ave Maria."
According to AP News reporting, "Trump bopped and shimmied onstage" during this extended musical interlude. The report also noted that "many of his supporters made their way to the exits, but some stayed through the end." This mixed audience response was not specifically addressed in the ABC News or NPR coverage.
As reported by AP News, Trump campaign spokesperson Steven Cheung characterized the event on social media platform X (formerly Twitter) as "something very special," adding that Trump "is unlike any politician in history." Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt posted a photo captioned "DJ TRUMP!" embracing the unconventional moment.
In official campaign statements provided to ABC News, Trump campaign press secretary Karoline Leavitt addressed the medical incidents, saying: "The safety and well-being of President Trump's supporters is always his top priority. The two individuals who fainted were immediately given medical attention. As President Trump said tonight, they are great patriots." Leavitt also characterized the event positively, stating: "To lighten the mood, President Trump turned the town hall into an impromptu concert and the crowd loved it... The room was full of joy."
ABC News exclusively reported that Trump addressed the unusual town hall the following day on his social media platform, calling the event "so different" and declaring "It ended up being a GREAT EVENING!" This follows Trump's statement during the event, as reported by AP News: "Those two people who went down are patriots. We love them. And because of them, we ended up with some great music, right?"
ABC News uniquely reported that "Vice President Kamala Harris was also in Pennsylvania on Monday evening stumping to voters in the critical battleground swing state whereas Trump largely dodged answering questions during the actual town hall portion of his event." The report further noted that Harris later responded to Trump's musical interlude by "repost[ing] a video of Trump swaying to music for nearly 45-minutes at his Oaks town hall on Monday, writing 'Hope he's okay.'"
This social media interaction highlights the increasingly digital nature of campaign messaging in the 2024 presidential race, with candidates responding to each other's events in near real-time through social platforms. The simultaneous Pennsylvania appearances by both candidates on October 14 demonstrates the state's significance in electoral strategy as the campaign enters its final weeks.
The three major news sources analyzed—ABC News, NPR, and Associated Press—each emphasized different aspects of the event, providing varying perspectives for their audiences:
ABC News provided the most detailed account of the medical emergencies and included exclusive reporting on Trump's post-event interaction with supporters. According to ABC, "Following the concert, Trump made his way to the front row, signing red MAGA hats and 47 signs. Trump's movement was noteworthy as he hasn't interacted with a large crowd to that extent since his attempted assassination in Butler, Pennsylvania." This contextualizes the event within Trump's modified campaign approach following the July 2024 security incident.
NPR's "All Things Considered" segment featured political correspondent Danielle Kurtzleben providing broader electoral context. NPR uniquely included Trump's recent comments from a Fox News interview with Maria Bartiromo where he discussed using military force against political opponents, stating: "I think the bigger problem are the people from within. We have some very bad people. We have some sick people, radical left lunatics. And I think they're the - and it should be very easily handled by, if necessary, by National Guard or, if really necessary, by the military." NPR also noted that Noem called Harris "stupid" during the town hall event.
The Associated Press offered the most comprehensive details about the musical selections and venue conditions. AP uniquely compared the town hall atmosphere to Trump's "winters at Mar-a-Lago, his South Florida estate, where he likes to play DJ and hold court with the wealthy members of his private club," providing context for Trump's affinity for musical curation.
All sources acknowledged Pennsylvania's importance in the 2024 presidential election. The decision by both major candidates to campaign in the state on the same day, October 14, just 22 days before Election Day, emphasizes Pennsylvania's status as a must-win battleground state.
The geographic location of this event in Oaks, Pennsylvania—part of Montgomery County in the Philadelphia suburbs—is strategically significant, as suburban voters in the Philadelphia metropolitan area represent a key demographic that could determine the state's electoral outcome. Both campaigns have focused significant resources on Pennsylvania throughout October 2024.
NPR framed the timing of this event within the broader campaign context, noting that with "just three weeks to go in the presidential campaign, the candidates are going full throttle." The coverage positioned this unusual town hall as occurring during a critical phase when "every event counts," making the unconventional format all the more notable.
NPR's analysis provided insight into the campaigns' focus during the final weeks before Election Day, noting: "They're not just trying to sway undecideds. They're trying to persuade people to vote, period." This context helps explain the divergent approaches of the two campaigns in Pennsylvania that day, with Trump emphasizing entertainment and emotional connection while Harris maintained a more traditional campaign approach.
The NPR segment suggested that at this late stage of the campaign, voter sentiment is largely fixed: "Broadly speaking, on both sides, voters are just very calcified. Nothing's going to swing people who are decided at this point, and there are very few people in the middle who can be swayed." This perspective frames Trump's unconventional town hall within a campaign strategy focused more on base enthusiasm than persuasion.
Articles Analyzed: ABC News, US News, and AP News
*There may be errors on this page.
Trump's October 2024 Pennsylvania Town Hall Musical Transition
Timelines Involved
- Event Date:
Youtube embed about Trump's October 2024 Pennsylvania Town Hall Musical Transition
Happening Now: Trump town hall in Pennsylvania - YouTube
Former President Trump is scheduled to appear at a town hall in Oaks, Pa. on Monday evening.During a rally in Prescott Valley, Ariz. on Sunday, Trump said th...